Insights

Cold outreach that leads with a demo

Cold outreach that leads with a demo

On 19 October I sent thirty cold emails to small businesses I had never spoken to. Each one opened with a link to a page I had already built: a one-page concept of that business's own website, made from their photos, their services and their words. One email bounced. One person asked not to hear from me again, and that request is permanent.

Why a demo instead of a pitch

A cold email is a stranger asking for attention. Most of them spend that attention describing the sender: years of experience, a list of services, a link to a portfolio full of other people's businesses. The reader has to imagine what any of it would mean for them, and most do not bother.

A demo skips the imagining. A landscaper opens the link and sees their own crew photos in a hero that moves, their own service list laid out so a customer can find it on a phone, their own phone number one tap away. They can judge it in ten seconds, without a call and without reading another word from me. If they like it, the conversation starts from something real. If they do not, I have learned something about their taste, and they have lost a minute.

Every demo is one page, deliberately. A single page that does a few things very well is easier to judge than a half-built site with five menus, and it is honest about what it is: a concept, not a finished product.

What goes in the email, in order

On 8 November I rewrote the rules for every pitch. My pitches until then had included a short audit of each business's current site: what was slow, what was missing, what a search engine might not like. It was accurate, and it was the wrong opening. Leading with someone's faults reads as criticism, however politely it is phrased, and nobody warms to a stranger who starts with what is wrong with their house.

So the demo goes first. Then a sentence or two on why I built it, which has to be true of the page they are about to open. The audit shrinks to a single line near the end, along the lines of "I also audited your current site and found a few spots for improvement", and the detail waits until someone asks for it.

Diagram of one cold email from top to bottom. 1, highlighted: the demo link, a one-page concept of their site built from their own photos, services and words. 2, why I built it, one or two sentences true of the page. 3, one line about their current site: I also audited your current site and found a few spots for improvement. 4, signature, then a small footer with a real postal address. 5, a plain line on how to opt out. 6, a P.S. only if something is time-sensitive and checked. Kept out of the email: a list of what is wrong with their site, any fact their own site does not state, prices or a specific deal. Checked before it is drafted: every claim against the live page that day, the demo scored 74 or higher by a critic, and the link opens the right page.
The order is the message: their site first, my opinion of their current one last and short.

Below the signature sits a small footer with a real postal address, and under that a plain line saying how to opt out. Neither is decoration. A physical address is part of what makes commercial email legitimate, and the opt-out line respects the fact that the reader never asked to hear from me.

The P.S. is the one place a specific finding is allowed, and only if it is time-sensitive: a renewal date about to pass, something that will break next week whether or not they ever hire me. Most emails have no P.S. at all.

Every claim is checked against the live page

The fastest way to lose a stranger's trust is to tell them something about their own business that is not true. So every line in a pitch is checked against their current site on the day the draft is written, and every fact in the demo must already appear on that site.

The checks have caught me more than once. One draft said a contractor held a particular licence. It may well be true, but their website did not say so, and a cold email is not the place to assert things a business has not said about itself. The line came out.

The other catch was a P.S. On 14 November a draft warned a business that the security certificate on its website was about to expire. That is exactly the sort of time-sensitive note the rules allow. Before the draft went into the ready pile, a live check showed the certificate was good until January 2027. The warning had come from an older reading. It was cut the same day, and I am glad it was caught by a check rather than by the owner.

The demo itself goes through the same discipline. Before any link reaches an email, the demo has been scored by a critic who did not build it and has cleared a bar of 74 out of 100. How that scoring works, and what it refuses to count, is in how I score a demo before a prospect sees it.

Timeline of autumn 2026. 19 October: the first thirty emails sent, each linking a demo; one bounced and one person asked not to hear from me again, which is permanent. 5 November, rule tightened: the demos moved to a new address and all 30 links already in inboxes were checked and still open the right page. 8 November, rule tightened: demo first, audit detail cut to one line near the end, and a postal address in every footer. 14 November, highlighted: a P.S. that was not true, a warning about an expiring security certificate that a live check showed was good until January, cut the same day. 15 November: 46 drafts read back, every body compared with what was approved, zero mismatches, and I press send myself.
Each rule answers something I saw in a real email, or nearly sent.

Links that keep working

A cold email can sit in an inbox for weeks before someone opens it. Whatever it links to has to still be there. In early November the demos moved to a new web address as the collection grew. The thirty emails from October all pointed at the old one. That evening the old address was set to forward each demo to its new home, and every one of the thirty links was opened and checked. All thirty land on the right page, and the old address stays switched on for as long as those emails exist.

A human presses send

Agents do a lot of this work. They build the demos, draft the emails, check the claims and read the drafts back. None of them sends anything. The drafts sit in my own mailbox, written there directly so the links stay exactly as written, and I send each one myself.

On 15 November the read-back covered 46 drafts. Each body was compared, line by line, with the version that had been approved, to make sure nothing had shifted between writing and saving. There were zero mismatches. Drafts whose demo was still being rebuilt were held back rather than sent with a promise the page could not yet keep.

The wider rules of email point the same way. Google's sender guidelines FAQ says that starting in November 2025 Gmail began ramping up enforcement against senders who do not meet its requirements. The strictest of those, such as one-click unsubscribe on marketing mail, apply to senders of 5,000 or more messages a day. I am nowhere near that volume, but the direction is plain enough for a small sender to follow. A handful of personal, checked emails, each with a way out, is a very different thing from a blast, and I want it to look different to the reader and to the inbox. The authentication behind that has also firmed up this year: on 20 May 2026 the IETF published the updated DMARC specification as a proper standard, the check that lets an inbox confirm an email really came from the domain it claims. The studio's own move to proper authenticated mail is in moving the studio's email to Google Workspace.

What I would tell another small business

If you reach out to people who have not heard of you, show them something that is about them, and make it good enough that they would want it even if they never wrote back. Keep your critique of their current situation to a sentence. Check every claim the morning you write it, because things change. Give them an easy way to say no, and honour it forever.

The batch that passed the read-back on 15 November sits in one labelled folder in my mailbox, each one opening with a link to a business's own website as it could be.

Common questions

What is in a demo?

A one-page concept of the business's own website, built from their real photos, services and words. It invents nothing their own site does not already say.

Why not lead with an audit of their current site?

Opening with someone's faults reads as criticism. The audit shrinks to one line near the end, and the detail is there if they ask.

Do AI agents send the emails?

No. Agents build the demos, draft the emails and check every claim, but the drafts sit in my own mailbox and I send each one myself.

Related

← All insights